
UPDATE October 2013: Israeli Government lays cruelty charges. Show details »
Following the exposure of systemic cruelty to Australian animals at Bakar Knuva abattoir, charges have been laid against four workers, including a manager. Click here for more details
UPDATE April 2013: Australian Government investigation fails to take action. Show details »
In April 2013 the Federal Department of Agriculture released the results of its investigation into this incident. The only action taken was to require a second audit of the facility which concluded that it was operating in accordance with ESCAS standards and DAFF again approved it to take Australian animals.
Incomprehensibly — DAFF did not investigate how the first audit could have overlooked key deficiencies and inappropriate practices to consider the abattoir appropriate in the first place.
DAFF also concluded that restraint devices that fully turn animals upside down to have their throats cut is acceptable under ESCAS. This is despite previous internal Australian government advice that full inversion of conscious cattle causes distress — it is in fact prohibited in Australia. This is a view supported by the UK Farm Animal Welfare Council which states: "Cattle inversion is a direct cause of avoidable pain, distress and suffering ..." ESCAS specifically requires animals to be handled and slaughtered in a way that does not cause 'undue stress', so the government's support of this method of restraint contradicts its own standards for the treatment of exported animals.
This investigation highlights serious flaws in Australia's live export regulations and how they are implemented and audited. It confirms once again that animals exported from our shores will always be at risk.
Please email your Federal MP — express your opposition to this cruel trade and demand that while it continues, there must be independent inspection and oversight in importing countries.
Bakar Tnuva is the largest slaughterhouse in Israel, and one of two abattoirs approved to take Australian animals under the government's new live export regulations.
Video footage taken in September - October 2012 shows Australian cattle being punched, kicked and beaten — with the worst cruelty inflicted on 'downer' animals who could no longer move or stand up. Evidence documented shows one lame bull poked with an electrified prodder over 100 times — in his face, eyes, ears, anus and genitals — the entire time bellowing in pain and distress as he made futile attempts to escape his tormentor. Painful electric prodders are used routinely in Bakar Tnuva to abuse animals.
Australian government audit reports indicate that Bakar Tnuva was audited in July 2012 — two months before this investigation — and was found to comply with the new Exporter Supply Chain Assurance System. In fact the only non-compliance picked up in the audit was a rusty gate, which has since been greased.
Bakar Tnuva passed its ESCAS audit despite the abattoir's routine procedures and entrenched behaviour of workers demonstrating multiple breaches of OIE and ESCAS guidelines. Show breaches »
- Use of a full inversion restraint box which tips cattle upside down for Kosher slaughter.
- Cattle being hoisted to the ceiling within 30 seconds of the throat cut and without confirmation of loss of consciousness.
- Routine failure to check animals are dead before further processing.
- Routine and deliberate use of electric prodders on animals who could no longer stand; who had nowhere to go; or who were already moving in the desired direction.
- Routine and deliberate use of electric prodders on sensitive areas including the eyes, face, genitalia and anus of cattle.
The auditors who 'inspected' and passed this facility were chosen and paid by the exporter. This presents a system that is completely untrustworthy.
Wherever animals are handled and slaughtered en masse there will be cruelty and suffering. But the failure of the Australian Government's system to ensure facilities can meet even the most basic standards is unforgivable. At the very least, the responsibility for ensuring that a facility can meet standards should rest with Australian government veterinarians.
Please email your Federal MP — express your opposition to this cruel trade and demand that while it continues, there must be independent inspection and oversight in importing countries.